In August and September 2012, Timothy Mullen entered his neighbour’s 40-acre property in Tilbury, Ontario, cut down a mature tree line of approximately 2,000 feet and filled in the drainage ditch beside it. The trees had separated the two farms. The court later found he did not have permission from the owner, Judith Ann Murphy. In 2018, the Ontario Superior Court held the defendants liable for trespass, and in 2020 it ordered them to pay $213,471.27 in damages. The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed their appeal in December 2021 and awarded Mrs Murphy costs of $20,000, all inclusive.
How the removal of the 2,000-foot tree line affected the neighbouring farm
According to the 2020 reasons for judgment of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, the Murphy property is 40 acres, and the Mullen property is 48 acres. A row of trees and a ditch ran along the west side of the Murphy property, between the two farms. The court described the tree line as “approximately 2,000 feet long”, running from the south end of the property at Highway 46 to an old railroad track at the north end. Mrs Murphy said it included trees of roughly 40 to 60 feet tall. The Court of Appeal for Ontario later described the line of trees as approximately 2,000 feet long and 60 feet deep, with the drainage ditch on the Murphy property.The 2020 judgment states that the tree line provided a sound and light barrier from a residential subdivision to the west, a wind break and a visual screen between the two properties, and “a home for various wildlife”. Mr Mullen bought his property in December 2010. According to the judgment, the land had no subsurface drainage, and he told the court, “I needed drainage on my property.” The Court of Appeal records that he entered the Murphy property, cut and removed the trees, and then filled in the ditch. In cross-examination, quoted in the 2018 ruling, he agreed that the entire tree line was removed. Mrs Murphy first learned of the removal in September 2012, when her son Jason attended the property.
Why the court ruled the tree cutting was unauthorised
The plaintiffs asked for summary judgment on liability for trespass, and Justice Pamela Hebner heard the motion on 8 January 2018. In her ruling of 10 July 2018, she noted that Mr Mullen admitted entering the property, cutting trees and levelling the ditch, so the issue was whether he had permission. Both parties pointed to a telephone call of 3 August 2012, which Mrs Murphy’s phone records showed lasted 16 minutes. Mrs Murphy said Mr Mullen told her he wanted to clean out the ditch and put in a new one, and that she asked to meet at the Comber Fair the following week to discuss it further. Mr Mullen said she agreed “as long as I saved her an oak log so she could make furniture out of it.”Justice Hebner found the evidence “consistent overall with a discussion as opposed to an agreement”. She noted that the meeting at the fair did not take place, because Mr Mullen did not go, and that Mr Mullen went onto the property the Friday after the fair. Mr Mullen had said that Mr Ian Pierce heard the call on speakerphone, but no affidavit from Mr Pierce was provided. The judge drew an adverse inference that he would not have supported Mr Mullen’s version. She also wrote that the burden of proving leave and licence lay with Mr Mullen and that he had not met it. She granted judgment on liability and set a hearing on damages.
Why the judge awarded more than $213,000 in damages
The damages hearing took place on 20 and 21 March and 5 and 6 September 2019, and the reasons were released on 26 February 2020. Mrs Murphy asked for $1,214,396, made up of $714,396 in special damages, $250,000 for loss of amenities and $250,000 in punitive damages. The defendants proposed $5,000, the cost of planting seedlings. Mrs Murphy’s arborist, Philip van Wassenaer, proposed 431 replacement trees along the full length of the former tree line, plus 50 poplar whips, at a total of $221,706. He also gave costs of $37,800 plus HST for irrigation and $39,750 plus HST for a deer fence. The judge applied the approach from the British Columbia case Kates v. Hall: the amount needed to pay for the remedial work that a reasonable person in the plaintiff’s position, without monetary constraints, would carry out. She accepted that Mrs Murphy intended to build a home on the southwest corner of the property, and found that a reasonable person would plant along one third of the 610-metre former hedge row, or approximately 200 metres.On that basis, the judge used one third of the arborist’s planting figure, $73,902, and assessed $20,000 for irrigation and $13,000 for fencing, giving $106,902 for restoration. She added $31,569.27 in out-of-pocket expenses, which included a survey that cost $6,440.59 and the cost of a municipal drain. The Court of Appeal records that the drain cost $102,000 in total under the Drainage Act, with $77,032 assessed to the Mullen property and $24,968 to the Murphy property. For loss of amenities, the judge took half of the 300 trees Mrs Murphy’s son had counted, which was 150 trees. She wrote that there was “some precedent” for $1,000 per tree but reduced it to $500 because there was no house on the property yet, giving $75,000. The total was $213,471.27. She declined to award punitive damages, finding the defendant’s conduct “reckless” but not high-handed enough to deserve rebuke.
Why the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the $213,000 damages award
The defendants appealed, and the Court of Appeal for Ontario heard the case by video conference on 20 September 2021. Justice Alexandra Hoy wrote the decision, with Justices Rouleau and Thorburn agreeing. According to the decision, the appellants did not contest liability but challenged the amount of damages, and the court grouped their arguments into four categories: foreseeability, Mrs Murphy’s intention to build a house and her affinity for trees, drainage, and other arguments. The court said it could interfere only if the trial judge erred in law, misapprehended the evidence or made a “palpably incorrect” or “wholly erroneous” assessment. On the drainage argument, it noted that the appellants called no expert evidence on whether the trees would have had to be removed anyway. On the number of trees, it noted that the expert’s 480 replacement trees were much smaller than the original trees, so a larger number was needed to create an equivalent screen within a reasonable period.The court also found there was evidence supporting the trial judge’s acceptance of the deer fence, and it described the 200-metre length and the $75,000 amenities figure as “far from arbitrary”. It concluded that the appellants had not identified any reviewable error and that the assessment was not palpably incorrect or wholly erroneous. The appeal was dismissed, with costs to Mrs Murphy of $20,000, all inclusive. The decision was released on 9 December 2021.
Discover more from updatview
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.