Mumbai: Bombay HC has quashed criminal proceedings against four men accused of abetting the suicide in 2019 of a 48-year-old man who believed his underage daughter had run away with one of them, observing that she had died by suicide months before the alleged elopement.Justice Milind N Jadhav observed that there was no material indicating any specific act of instigation or intentional assistance by the four that could have driven the man to suicide.The father allegedly jumped in front of a moving train at Tilak Nagar station on Oct 13, 2019. Police claimed that in five handwritten chits recovered from his pocket, he blamed some persons for driving him to suicide.According to the prosecution, the man had lodged a complaint at Nehru Nagar police station on April 25 that year, alleging that his daughter had been lured away by one of the men. He was allegedly under severe mental distress as he believed that the accused were keeping her away from him and preventing her from contacting him.But the investigation showed that the daughter had died by suicide on March 30 that year and had not eloped as her father had suspected. Police believed he did not know about it.The additional chief judicial magistrate, Esplanade court, discharged the accused of kidnapping and wrongful confinement in June 2025 after accepting police’s closure report. The prosecution appealed this in a sessions court. The accused later moved HC to quash the proceedings.The four applicants, through advocates Ramprasad Gupta and Rohit Vaishwa, questioned the authenticity and handling of the five suicide notes, pointing out that the inquest panchnama did not clearly record their recovery from the man’s pocket. They said the notes’ contents had circulated in the area immediately after the death, raising questions.The defence pointed out that the father’s phone was produced nearly a month after his death in a damaged condition with a non-functional display. The four argued that the investigation had failed to explain the delay or examine allegations in the suicide note against the then senior police inspector.The court observed that the circumstances surrounding the recovery and preservation of the five chits, along with the delayed production of the phone, raised serious doubts about the investigation.Relying on Supreme Court judgments, HC held that criminal proceedings could be quashed in respect of specific persons without necessarily terminating the case against all accused. It clarified that its order would not affect the proceedings against the remaining accused.
Discover more from updatview
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.