CBI’s bribery case against Chanda Kochhar halts as Bombay HC quashes bank’s prosecution nod | Mumbai News


CBI’s bribery case against Chanda Kochhar halts as Bombay HC quashes bank’s prosecution nod
CBI’s bribery case against Chanda Kochhar halts as Bombay HC quashes bank’s prosecution nod

Mumbai: Holding that it was illegal, Bombay HC on Wednesday quashed and set aside the sanction granted by ICICI Bank in 2023 to prosecute its former MD and CEO, Chanda Kochhar, over alleged irregularities in loans provided to Venugopal Dhoot-led Videocon Group between 2009 and 2011. It said the authority that gave the nod “completely failed to apply its mind” and the competent authority in this case—RBI—had passed no such sanction order.It set aside the consequential actions taken by the special court in the CBI case pursuant to the sanction order.The HC order means CBI cannot proceed against Kochhar under Prevention of Corruption Act and its case against her falls. The agency can appeal the ruling.Justice Milind Jadhav said the “power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only”. “No reasons are given by RBI for removal of the petitioner (Kochhar)… Reasons for removal/sanction order are not recorded in writing by RBI,” HC said.It noted that nullity of sanction goes to the “root of the prosecution’s case” and stands on the “same pedestal as absent sanction”.Kochhar had petitioned HC in 2024 to challenge as illegal the sanction granted by ICICI Bank’s board of directors to prosecute her. Senior counsel Aabad Ponda, representing her, argued that prior sanction is necessary for any prosecution of a public servant under Prevention of Corruption Act’s Section 19, which had been invoked against her. A bank employee is considered a public servant. Ponda said the sanction was illegal as it failed to even specify the offences for which it is granted, as mandatory under the law. Besides, he said, the bank’s board of directors was not the “competent authority” to grant the sanction under the Act.HC agreed. It said the sanction was granted by an “incompetent authority”, rendering it “illegal and a nullity”.It said even the “cognisance taken by the special court of the offence under the Act is illegal and deserves to be set aside”. “Though it is true that the trial has not commenced, the very fact that cognisance is taken on the basis of the impugned defective sanction itself nullifies all past and future procedure followed by the special court,” HC said.Ponda argued that law empowered RBI to remove a chairperson, director, chief executive officer or other officer or employee of a banking company and, therefore, it was the competent authority to remove Kochhar, and not the bank’s board of directors. HC concurred.Additional solicitor general Anil Singh for CBI argued that Kochhar herself had said the bank’s board was the competent authority and stood precluded from now arguing that it was not. “I cannot countenance” it, as such a submission cannot be used to bypass legal provisions, said Justice Jadhav. Besides, the law mandates a “reasonable opportunity” for a representation to RBI when removing such high-ranking officers, HC noted.Only a letter addressed by CBI and its report, not the material collected by the agency, were placed before the bank’s board of directors to decide on the sanction, HC observed.HC said the sanction order was “unsustainable in law, being a nullity” and deserved to be quashed and set aside. It declined a request by CBI lawyer Kuldeep Patil to stay its judgment for eight weeks to enable the agency to go in for an appeal.CBI had lodged an FIR in 2019 under Indian Penal Code and Prevention of Corruption Act against Kochhar, husband Deepak, Dhoot, Nupower Renewables and Videocon Industries for allegedly defrauding ICICI Bank of Rs 1,730 crore till March 2012. Kochhar was prosecuted for conspiring with other co-accused in sanctioning a term loan of Rs 300 crore to Videocon Group. CBI arrested her and her husband, Deepak Kochhar, on Dec 23, 2022. HC granted them interim bail on Jan 9, 2023, observing that the arrest memos appeared “casual, mechanical and perfunctory, clearly without application of mind.” In June that year, CBI told the special court that ICICI Bank’s board had granted prosecution sanction against Kochhar on April 22, citing an apparent quid pro quo.



Source link


Discover more from updatview

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from updatview

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading