Mumbai man ports 26-year-old mediclaim policy from United India Insurance, pays Rs 56,036 premium for Rs 25 lakh cover; Care Health denies cashless treatment for brain aneurysm citing non-disclosure of Bell’s Palsy; consumer commission awards Rs 35,000 | Mumbai News


Mumbai man ports 26-year-old mediclaim policy from United India Insurance, pays Rs 56,036 premium for Rs 25 lakh cover; Care Health denies cashless treatment for brain aneurysm citing non-disclosure of Bell’s Palsy; consumer commission awards Rs 35,000
AI Generated Image Used For Representational Purpose Only

MUMBAI: The Central Mumbai District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission recently held that an insurer cannot deny cashless pre-authorisation after portability by treating an intervening ailment during continuous insurance coverage as an undisclosed pre-existing disease, particularly without establishing any link between the ailment and the illness for which the claim was made. The commission partly allowed a complaint filed by Wadala-based Mehul Gandhi against Care Health Insurance Limited, awarding him Rs 35,000 in total — Rs 30,000 as compensation and Rs 5,000 as costs.Gandhi had originally held a mediclaim policy with United India Insurance Company since March 1996, covering himself, his wife and daughter. In September 2022, he ported the policy to Care Health Insurance after paying a premium of Rs 56,036. The policy issued by Care Health Insurance provided coverage of Rs 25 lakh and was valid from September 23, 2022, to September 22, 2023.According to the complaint filed in 2023, Gandhi disclosed during the telephonic process that he and his wife were taking medication for hypertension, while their daughter had previously been treated for a throat infection. In December 2022, Gandhi felt lightheaded at Igatpuri and underwent medical tests, including an MRI. He was diagnosed with an intracranial aneurysm, a life-threatening condition requiring surgery estimated to cost around Rs 20 lakh.Gandhi sought cashless pre-authorisation for the surgery. Care Health Insurance sought past medical records relating to Bell’s Palsy in 2009 and syncope (fainting or passing out) in 2021. Gandhi’s doctor clarified that Bell’s Palsy had been treated at home in 2009 and that the 2021 syncope episode was a brief fainting reaction during routine blood collection. The insurer nevertheless denied cashless pre-authorisation on January 6, 2023, citing non-disclosure of Bell’s Palsy as a pre-existing ailment.The commission noted that Gandhi had sought reimbursement of the actual cost of an operation that was yet to be performed. On this claim, the commission observed, “Admittedly, the complainant has not undergone any operation uptil now for the said illness. As rightly contended by the opposite party cashless pre authorization is just a facility. Therefore, unless the actual treatment is being obtained by the complainant, there cannot be any claim.”The commission therefore held that the demand for the cost of future surgery was premature. However, it found fault with the insurer’s denial of cashless approval. The commission recorded that Gandhi had continuous insurance coverage from 1996 until he ported the policy in 2022, and that portability carries forward the continuity of benefits. It observed, “Therefore, the Bell’s Palsy occurred in the year 2009 and syncope treatment taken in the year 2021 occurred during the subsistence of continuous coverage under United India policy.”The commission further observed that these conditions could not be treated as undisclosed pre-existing diseases at the time of porting the policy in 2022. It stated, “Therefore, the same cannot be treated as undisclosed pre-existing disease at the time of porting in the year 2022.”Care Health Insurance relied on hospital medical notes dated December 14, 2022, which recorded a history of Bell’s Palsy dating back to 2009. The commission rejected this as sufficient proof of suppression of medical information. It held, “Recording of past history by doctor is not suppression and it is not the proof of suppression of material facts. There must be nexus between non-disclosed ailment and claim.”The commission also noted that Gandhi had produced a certificate stating that the intracranial aneurysm was unrelated to Bell’s Palsy. The insurer, however, did not produce expert evidence to establish any connection between the two conditions. The commission observed, “The Opposite Party has not brought on record any expert evidence to show that if Bell’s Palsy occurred in the year 2009 has nexus with the intracranial aneurysm.”Holding that the insurer’s conduct had caused injury to Gandhi, the commission concluded, “Therefore, due to the conduct of the Opposite Party to deny the pre authorization of cashless hospitalisation on the basis of pre-existing disease, which has no nexus with the existing disease has caused the injury to the complainant, which amounts to unfair trade practice.”The final order stated, “The Opposite Party is declared of adopting the unfair trade practice,” and directed Care Health Insurance to pay Rs 30,000 as compensation and Rs 5,000 as costs within 60 days of receiving the order.



Source link


Discover more from updatview

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from updatview

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading