An Alabama woman supported her husband while he trained as a surgeon, but their divorce excluded his medical-business interests from marital assets; an appeals court reversed that division and ordered a new review


An Alabama woman supported her husband while he trained as a surgeon, but their divorce excluded his medical-business interests from marital assets; an appeals court reversed that division and ordered a new review
His wife had supported the household while he completed medical training. (AI image)

An Alabama appeals court has overturned part of a divorce settlement after finding that a lower court wrongly excluded a surgeon’s medical-business investments from the couple’s marital assets. The woman had worked and helped meet household expenses while her husband completed medical training. The case has now been sent back for a fresh assessment of the couple’s property.Sarah Gordon and Charles Gordon married in 2011, the year Charles completed medical school. He subsequently underwent an internship, a five-year orthopaedic surgery residency and a spine-surgery fellowship. During this period, Sarah worked as a nanny and took up other jobs to help pay household expenses.Charles completed his fellowship in 2018, after which the couple moved to Baldwin County. He joined Baldwin Bone and Joint, an orthopaedic practice, and became a partner in 2020 or 2021 after borrowing money from First Horizon Bank. Sarah, meanwhile, became a full-time homemaker and had no separate income.In its November 20, decision, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals ruled that the husband’s business interests should have been considered marital property. It reversed the property division and directed the lower court to determine their value and reconsider the distribution. However, it did not specify what share Sarah should receive.

Financial disputes during divorce

Sarah filed for divorce in February 2024. The trial court subsequently ordered the couple to maintain their existing financial arrangements and prohibited them from disposing of assets acquired during the marriage without permission.Sarah later accused Charles of restricting her access to bank accounts and credit cards. She also alleged that he had withdrawn around $183,000 from their joint checking account.Under a temporary agreement adopted by the court in October 2024, Charles was required to place the withdrawn money in an interest-bearing account, resume depositing his salary into the joint account and transfer another $20,000. He was also directed to restore Sarah’s access to their financial accounts.Sarah subsequently alleged that Charles had issued three cheques totalling $19,400 after depositing the additional money. She also complained that he had again restricted her access to the joint account.Charles admitted during the trial that he had stopped depositing his salary into the account around May 2024 and again around February 2025. He also acknowledged removing Sarah as an authorised credit-card user, saying her spending exceeded what he could afford.

Court rejects request to postpone trial

In October 2025, Sarah sought $30,000 towards expert assistance and legal expenses, saying she needed professionals to examine her husband’s assets.The final hearing was scheduled for December 8, 2025. Three days before the trial, she sought a postponement, saying she could not afford a forensic accountant and had recently discovered a bank account and credit card for which she had not received records.The trial judge rejected the request, noting that the divorce case had been pending since February 2024.The appeals court upheld that decision. It said Sarah had raised the need for expert assistance in October but waited until shortly before the hearing to seek a postponement. Her lawyer had also failed to explain what an accountant might discover or how the findings would affect the case.

Medical businesses should be included

The main issue in the appeal was Charles’s ownership interests in Baldwin Bone and Joint, a surgery centre and other medical consulting businesses.During the trial, Sarah submitted an assessment estimating that Charles’s 15.38% interest in Baldwin Bone and Joint Medical Center, LLC, was worth $219,491. The calculation was based on a September 2025 balance sheet.The lower court admitted the document but treated the business as Charles’s separate estate. It also declined to accept a tax document relating to the surgery centre as a valuation. Charles had invested $150,000 in that centre but maintained that its shares were “worth nothing” because the business was operating at a loss.The appeals court found that the business interests had been acquired during the marriage. Charles completed his medical training seven years after the wedding and purchased his medical-practice partnership interest in 2020 or 2021. There was no evidence that he had acquired these interests before marriage or received them through gifts or inheritance.Under the law, property accumulated during marriage can form part of the marital estate. The appeals court said the lower court had no sufficient evidence to classify the businesses as Charles’s separate property.Charles argued that the lower court had already accounted for the investments through a $70,000 property settlement awarded to Sarah. However, that payment covered several matters, including retirement-account adjustments, moving expenses and his violations of earlier court orders.The lower court had neither valued the businesses nor specified how much of the settlement was intended to compensate Sarah for them. The appeals court therefore found that the payment did not correct the error in excluding the businesses from the marital estate.

Home, vehicle and alimony issues

The appeals court also addressed the couple’s marital home. The lower court had recorded its equity as $100,000, describing the figure as an agreement between the parties. Sarah disputed this and argued that the equity was $150,000, based on a $1.5 million appraisal and a $1.35 million mortgage.The appeals court found no clear agreement on the amount and directed the lower court to determine the equity from the evidence.It also ordered the lower court to consider the Mercedes G-Wagon, which had been excluded because it belonged to an LLC, alongside the valuation of the business interests.The court left the decision not to award Sarah a vehicle unchanged because she had testified that she did not hold a valid driving licence at the time of the trial.It also allowed the lower court to reconsider alimony after completing the revised property division, as the two issues are connected.The appeals court upheld the refusal to postpone the trial and the decision not to hold Charles in contempt or impose additional sanctions.It ultimately reversed the division of marital property and sent the case back to the Baldwin Circuit Court. The lower court must now value the medical-business interests, include them in the marital estate and reconsider an equitable division of the couple’s assets.



Source link


Discover more from updatview

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from updatview

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading